Current Match Time:
If you're here, you're probably already thinking about baby number two—even while you're still in the middle of your first surrogacy journey.
At American Surrogacy, we completely understand that eagerness and we’re here to help you navigate this next step with efficiency and care.
Ready to start exploring staggered surrogacy sibling journeys? Let’s talk about how to make it happen with a plan that fits your family’s unique goals.
Whether your first surrogate is just entering her second trimester or you're cuddling your newborn at home, this guide will walk you through how to begin your surrogacy sibling journey the right way.
What Is a Surrogacy Sibling Journey?
A surrogacy sibling journey is when a family pursues a second surrogacy to give their first child a sibling. You might be just a few months into your first journey, or perhaps you’re already holding your first baby in your arms.
Either way, your heart’s in the same place: ready to complete your family.
We know it’s tempting to move quickly. You’ve waited long enough to become parents. But the timing of your second surrogacy journey matters and that’s where we come in to help you get it right.
Can We Pursue Two Surrogacy Journeys at the Same Time?
While we don’t support tandem journeys (initiating two surrogate pregnancies at the same time), you can begin planning your second surrogacy journey as soon as your first surrogate reaches 20 weeks of pregnancy.
At that point:
We can start your matching process for the next surrogate. You can begin a new IVF cycle if needed. You’ll still have time to focus on the remainder of your first journey while feeling confident that progress is underway.
We’ve found this timeline gives families a sense of momentum while also ensuring a safe, supported and healthy outcome for everyone involved.
Our Programs for Staggered Surrogacy Sibling Journeys
At American Surrogacy, we offer three surrogacy programs designed to meet different needs and levels of financial protection, whether you’re preparing for your first baby or planning your surrogacy sibling journey.
Families pursuing a staggered dual surrogacy can choose different programs for each experience.
For example:
-
If you start with our Limited Risk Program for peace of mind, then move to the Foundation Program for more flexibility and lower costs in your second surrogacy journey.
-
If you began with our Independent Program using a surrogate you found on your own, you're welcome to use our Limited Risk Program later when you need help finding a surrogate.
Our programs come with expert case management, and our two matching programs are built to move efficiently with typical wait times of just 1 - 4 months.
Limited Risk Program: Premium Protection & Peace of Mind
For families who want more financial security and predictability, this plan offers greater peace of mind by protecting you from paying the same fees over and over again if things don't go as planned.
If your surrogate isn’t approved by the clinic, a transfer is unsuccessful or a miscarriage occurs, many fees will either roll over to your next attempt or be refunded.
Dig deeper: Protect what matters most.
Foundation Program: Flexible Path to Parenthood
This plan is a good fit for families who want lower upfront costs and greater flexibility. It follows a traditional fee structure and works well if everything goes smoothly on the first attempt.
If your first embryo transfer is successful, your total cost can stay on the lower end. However, if you need to rematch or complete multiple transfers, your costs may increase, as those steps would need to be repeated.
Dig deeper: Tailor your journey to fit your budget.
Independent Program: We'll Handle the Rest
If you’ve already found your surrogate independently but still want expert guidance, our Independent Program may be a good fit.
Dig deeper: Get support where you need it.
Why We Stagger Dual Surrogacy Journeys: Our Agency Philosophy
When you stagger your second surrogacy journey, you give yourself, your surrogate(s) and your future children the best possible foundation for success.
Here’s how:
If any issues come up in the first pregnancy, your full focus needs to be there. A staggered plan allows room to adapt without added pressure. Surrogates want to feel valued and supported. Focusing on one journey at a time helps ensure that. Spacing out births (by at least nine months) supports healthy sibling development and a smoother transition for your growing family. With a staggered approach, you can continue forward momentum without rushing critical decisions like legal steps, budgeting and embryo planning.
Understanding Surrogate Concerns About Staggered Journeys
Even when dual surrogacy journeys are staggered and well-timed, some surrogates may still feel uncertain. They may worry about:
-
Sharing the emotional space of their journey with another surrogate
-
Not receiving the time and focus she needs
-
Communication being infrequent or inconsistent
-
Priorities shifting unexpectedly if one pregnancy or birth has complications
These are very real and valid concerns. We recommend that you consider these possibilities as part of your planning and be ready to talk openly with your potential surrogate.
If questions arise on a match call, having a thoughtful, compassionate response can go a long way in reassuring your surrogate that she will be supported, respected and prioritized throughout the journey.
Matching with the Same Surrogate: Is It Possible?
Yes! If your original surrogate is healthy, willing and ready, we can explore that path together.
Why families love this option:
-
Trust is already built.
-
Continuity in having both children carried by the same amazing woman.
Most clinics require surrogates to wait at least 6 to 12 months postpartum before undergoing another embryo transfer, with some recommending a longer recovery period of up to 18 months.
This recovery window could slow down your timeline compared to matching with a different surrogate for a staggered journey.
We can help you find your second surrogate just as quickly as we did your first.
Dual Staggered Journeys vs. Waiting Until After the First Birth
If you’re not sure whether to start your surrogacy sibling journey during your current one or wait until after your first child is born, here’s how to think about it:
Staggered Journey
-
Keeps the momentum going
-
Can shorten your total timeline to family completion
-
Lets you thoughtfully plan without rushing
Waiting Until After the Birth of Your First Baby
-
Full focus on adjusting to your first child
-
Clear emotional space for bonding and reflection
-
Less pressure on your schedule and finances
There’s no “right” answer, just what’s best for your family right now. And we’ll help you figure that out.
Financial Considerations for a Second Journey
We understand the desire to keep building your family and how exciting it is to begin your surrogacy sibling journey as soon as possible. But it’s important to take a thoughtful look at the financial side of things before moving forward with a staggered dual journey.
If you're considering starting your second surrogacy journey early, make sure you're confident in your financial readiness.
Need more time? That’s completely okay. Some families choose to wait until their first journey is complete before reassessing their finances and beginning the next step. Either way, we’re here to help.
Worried about covering the costs of staggered surrogacy journeys? Learn about financing options, grants and how to plan for each stage of the process.
Your Second Surrogacy Starts Here: Let’s Build Your Family Together
Your next surrogacy journey is just as important as your first. Let’s build the next chapter of your family with expert support, emotional care and a team that’s fully committed to your vision.